San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus: Difference between revisions
The Admins (talk | contribs) |
The Admins (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
==July 2021 "pedophilia" controversy== | ==July 2021 "pedophilia" controversy== | ||
SFGMC generated controversy<ref name=PinkNews>[https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2021/07/09/sf-gay-mens-chorus-song-alex-jones/ Emma Powys Maurice (July 9, 2021). "Right-wing cranks flip out over hilarious Gay Men's Chorus song about grooming kids and teaching tolerance". ''Pink News.'']</ref><ref>[https://www.foxnews.com/us/san-francisco-gay-mens-chorus-your-children FOX News on the controversy]</ref> when they released a song on YouTube on July 1, 2021 titled ''"A Message from the Gay Community"''. The lyrics were by Charlie Sohne and music by Tim Rosser with the chorus featuring lead vocals by Troy Iwata and Daniel Quadrino. The song talked about "converting" children to the [[Historical examples of LGBT-MAP unity|gay rights movement]], and included lines such as "We're coming for your children", "You won't approve of where they go at night", and "You think that we'll corrupt your kids if our agenda goes unchecked... Funny, just this once, you're correct". There was a strong negative reaction to the song online from right wing outlets, with TMZ reporting that the group received death threats,<ref name=TMZ>[https://www.tmz.com/2021/07/09/san-francisco-gay-mens-chorus-convert-your-children-controversial-song-backlash-death-threats/ San Francsico Gay Men's Chorus We're Standing By Controversial Song ... In Face Of Death Threats. ''TMZ.'']</ref> and the video was temporarily set to private | SFGMC generated controversy<ref name=PinkNews>[https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2021/07/09/sf-gay-mens-chorus-song-alex-jones/ Emma Powys Maurice (July 9, 2021). "Right-wing cranks flip out over hilarious Gay Men's Chorus song about grooming kids and teaching tolerance". ''Pink News.'']</ref><ref>[https://www.foxnews.com/us/san-francisco-gay-mens-chorus-your-children FOX News on the controversy]</ref> when they released a song on YouTube on July 1, 2021 titled ''"A Message from the Gay Community"''. The lyrics were by Charlie Sohne and music by Tim Rosser with the chorus featuring lead vocals by Troy Iwata and Daniel Quadrino. The song talked about "converting" children to the [[Historical examples of LGBT-MAP unity|gay rights movement]], and included lines such as "We're coming for your children", "You won't approve of where they go at night", and "You think that we'll corrupt your kids if our agenda goes unchecked... Funny, just this once, you're correct". There was a strong negative reaction to the song online from right wing outlets, with TMZ reporting that the group received death threats,<ref name=TMZ>[https://www.tmz.com/2021/07/09/san-francisco-gay-mens-chorus-convert-your-children-controversial-song-backlash-death-threats/ San Francsico Gay Men's Chorus We're Standing By Controversial Song ... In Face Of Death Threats. ''TMZ.'']</ref> and the video was temporarily set to private. | ||
===Reactionary outrage=== | ===Reactionary outrage=== | ||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
Alt-Right personality, Alex Jones, for example, opined: | Alt-Right personality, Alex Jones, for example, opined: | ||
<blockquote>''The song is not shy about what the San Francisco Gay Men’s Chorus hopes to accomplish, repeatedly singing, ‘We’re coming for them, we’re coming for your children.’ That’s not creepy or paedophilic at all…''<ref name=PinkNews /></blockquote> | |||
Other conservative outlets described the song's writers, Charlie Sohne and Tim Rosser as "pro-pedophile", pointing to previous work on the subject of [[Bacha Bazi]] (dancing boys).<ref>[https://spectator.org/gay-choir-children/ American Spectator: ‘We’ll Convert Your Children,’ Says Gay Men’s Choir]</ref><ref>[https://rairfoundation.com/exposed-pro-pedophilia-writers-behind-lgbt-song-threatening-to-convert-your-children-video/ RAIR: EXPOSED: Pro-Pedophilia Writers Behind LGBT Song Threatening to 'Convert Your Children' (Video)]</ref> | |||
:'' | SFGMC then restored their video and released a statement: | ||
<blockquote>''The far-right conservative media found our ‘Message…’ video and have taken it as their cause. This has all happened in the last 24 hours and it continues to pick up steam [...] They have taken the lyrics out of context to support a narrative that suits their intolerant and hateful needs. It is obvious the tongue-in-cheek humour is lost on many [...] As a result, we have seen the user comments on YouTube, Facebook and Instagram become increasingly alarming. Emails to individuals and the chorus office are vitriolic – including threats of harm. [...] [the controversy] proves that our message is critically necessary in today’s world… we will continue to counter the message of hate by teaching young people to be tolerant and fair.''<ref name=PinkNews /></blockquote> | |||
Right-wing commentators then reacted with further outrage, stating that in the SFGMC's own words, the video could not have been satirical. One fringe website named ''"Evangelical Dark Web"'' even attempted to imply that SFGMC likely contained numerous sex offenders - leading to a further wave of controversy on social media.<ref>[https://evangelicaldarkweb.org/2021/07/14/san-francisco-gay-mens-chorus-full-list-of-possible-sex-offenders/ Evangelical Dark Web - Suggests numerous RSOs in SFGMC]</ref> The methods used in this matching process are likely to be questionable.<ref>[https://misbar.com/en/factcheck/2021/07/16/far-right-news-sites-spread-false-claims-about-san-francisco-gay-mens-choir Misbar Fact Check]</ref> | Right-wing commentators then reacted with further outrage, stating that in the SFGMC's own words, the video could not have been satirical. One fringe website named ''"Evangelical Dark Web"'' even attempted to imply that SFGMC likely contained numerous sex offenders - leading to a further wave of controversy on social media.<ref>[https://evangelicaldarkweb.org/2021/07/14/san-francisco-gay-mens-chorus-full-list-of-possible-sex-offenders/ Evangelical Dark Web - Suggests numerous RSOs in SFGMC]</ref> The methods used in this matching process are likely to be questionable.<ref>[https://misbar.com/en/factcheck/2021/07/16/far-right-news-sites-spread-false-claims-about-san-francisco-gay-mens-choir Misbar Fact Check]</ref> | ||
Revision as of 20:48, 19 March 2023
The San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus (SFGMC), according to Wikipedia, is the world's first openly gay chorus, one of the world's largest male choruses, and the group most often credited with creating the LGBT choral movement.
July 2021 "pedophilia" controversy
SFGMC generated controversy[1][2] when they released a song on YouTube on July 1, 2021 titled "A Message from the Gay Community". The lyrics were by Charlie Sohne and music by Tim Rosser with the chorus featuring lead vocals by Troy Iwata and Daniel Quadrino. The song talked about "converting" children to the gay rights movement, and included lines such as "We're coming for your children", "You won't approve of where they go at night", and "You think that we'll corrupt your kids if our agenda goes unchecked... Funny, just this once, you're correct". There was a strong negative reaction to the song online from right wing outlets, with TMZ reporting that the group received death threats,[3] and the video was temporarily set to private.
Reactionary outrage
Social Media Conservatives appeared to misinterpret both the satirical nature of the performance, and its attempts at promoting tolerance - particularly among the children of non-LGBT people.
Alt-Right personality, Alex Jones, for example, opined:
The song is not shy about what the San Francisco Gay Men’s Chorus hopes to accomplish, repeatedly singing, ‘We’re coming for them, we’re coming for your children.’ That’s not creepy or paedophilic at all…[1]
Other conservative outlets described the song's writers, Charlie Sohne and Tim Rosser as "pro-pedophile", pointing to previous work on the subject of Bacha Bazi (dancing boys).[4][5]
SFGMC then restored their video and released a statement:
The far-right conservative media found our ‘Message…’ video and have taken it as their cause. This has all happened in the last 24 hours and it continues to pick up steam [...] They have taken the lyrics out of context to support a narrative that suits their intolerant and hateful needs. It is obvious the tongue-in-cheek humour is lost on many [...] As a result, we have seen the user comments on YouTube, Facebook and Instagram become increasingly alarming. Emails to individuals and the chorus office are vitriolic – including threats of harm. [...] [the controversy] proves that our message is critically necessary in today’s world… we will continue to counter the message of hate by teaching young people to be tolerant and fair.[1]
Right-wing commentators then reacted with further outrage, stating that in the SFGMC's own words, the video could not have been satirical. One fringe website named "Evangelical Dark Web" even attempted to imply that SFGMC likely contained numerous sex offenders - leading to a further wave of controversy on social media.[6] The methods used in this matching process are likely to be questionable.[7]
See also
External links
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Emma Powys Maurice (July 9, 2021). "Right-wing cranks flip out over hilarious Gay Men's Chorus song about grooming kids and teaching tolerance". Pink News.
- ↑ FOX News on the controversy
- ↑ San Francsico Gay Men's Chorus We're Standing By Controversial Song ... In Face Of Death Threats. TMZ.
- ↑ American Spectator: ‘We’ll Convert Your Children,’ Says Gay Men’s Choir
- ↑ RAIR: EXPOSED: Pro-Pedophilia Writers Behind LGBT Song Threatening to 'Convert Your Children' (Video)
- ↑ Evangelical Dark Web - Suggests numerous RSOs in SFGMC
- ↑ Misbar Fact Check