Debate Guide: Difference between revisions

From NewgonWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
(21 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
__NOTOC__
__NOTITLE__
:'''''You are viewing an incomplete version of Debate Guide. For a fuller version, see [http://debate-guide.com here].'''''
<div style="font-size:10%; color:#fff;">
:''[http://newgon.com/forum/viewtopic.php?id=506 Feedback Forum available]''
G O O G L E B O M B, BoyLover, GirlLover, Childlove, Pedophilia, Child, Rape, Sick, Evil, Jack McClellan, Pedo, Perverted Justice, Satanic Ritual Abuse, Human Trafficking, The truth about Paedophilia, Michael Jackson Pedophilia, Sarah Payne Murder, Soham Murders, NSPCC child abuse, Bruce Rind, PNVD pedophilia, pedophile party, pedopartij, NAMBLA, Daniel Lièvre, Tom O'Carroll, Paedophilia in Britain, USA, American pedophilia, Paedophile Information Exchange, UNCRC Convention, Children's rights, Child protection, Child sexual abuse, every child matters, debate, win arguments, discussion, pedobear, forum, bbs, bulletin board, loli, castorama, ricrisci, notamonster G O O G L E B O M B</div>
__NOTOC__
{|class="boilerplate" id="pd" style="width:80%; -moz-border-radius: 1em; margin: 0 auto; border:3px solid black; padding:5px; background-color:#57E964;" cellpadding="4" cellspacing="4"
|<center>
[[Image:Dg.png]]
Debate Guide is a growing list of arguments and counter arguments for the sexual emancipation of minors and minor attracted adults. It also functions as centre for advice, links and external debate resources pertaining to these issues and the age of consent. Why not consider [[Introduction to Debate Guide|'''reading our introduction''']] or [[NewgonWiki:Getting involved|'''getting involved''']] in the wider wiki project?</center>
|}
<br>
{|id="mp-upper" style="margin:0px 0px 0px 0px; background:none;"
|class="MainPageBG" style="width:50%; border:3px solid #000; background:white; vertical-align:top; color:white;"|
{|id="mp-left" width="100%"; cellpadding="2" cellspacing="5" style="vertical-align:top; background:white;"


Debate Guide is a growing list of arguments and counter arguments for the sexual emancipation of minors and minor attracted adults.
! <h2 id="mp-tfa-h2" style="margin:0; background:#BCE954; font-size:120%; font-weight:bold; border:1px solid #a3bfb1; text-align:left; color:white; padding:0.2em 0.4em;">Advice</h2>
|-
|style="color:#000;"| <div id="mp-tfa">{{Debate Guide:Advice}}</div>
|-
! <h2 id="mp-otd-h2" style="margin:0; background:#BCE954; font-size:120%; font-weight:bold; border:1px solid #a3b0bf; text-align:left; color:white; padding:0.2em 0.4em;">Arguments about pedophilia/other attractions</h2>
|-
|style="color:#000;"| <div id="mp-otd">{{Debate Guide:Arguments about pedophilia/other attractions}}</div>
|-
! <h2 id="mp-dyk-h2" style="margin:0; background:#BCE954; font-size:120%; font-weight:bold; border:1px solid #a3bfb1; text-align:left; color:white; padding:0.2em 0.4em;">Arguments about children and minors</h2>
|-
|style="color:#000;"| <div id="mp-dyk">{{Debate Guide:Arguments about children and minors}}</div>
|}
|style="border:1px solid transparent"|<!--
--------------------------------2nd Column------------------------------->
| class="MainPageBG" style="width:50%; border:3px solid #000; background:white; vertical-align:top;"|
{|id="mp-right" width="100%" cellpadding="2" cellspacing="5" style="vertical-align:top; background:white;"
! <h2 id="mp-itn-h2" style="margin:0; background:#BCE954; font-size:120%; font-weight:bold; border:1px solid #a3b0bf; text-align:left; color:white; padding:0.2em 0.4em;">Arguments about adult-minor relationships</h2>
|-
|style="color:#000;"| <div id="mp-itn">{{Debate Guide:Arguments about adult-minor relationships}}</div>
|-
! <h2 id="mp-otd-h2" style="margin:0; background:#BCE954; font-size:120%; font-weight:bold; border:1px solid #a3b0bf; text-align:left; color:white; padding:0.2em 0.4em;">Other arguments</h2>
|-
|style="color:#000;"| <div id="mp-otd">{{Debate Guide:Other arguments}}</div>
|}
|}
<br>
{|class="boilerplate" id="pd" style="width:92%; -moz-border-radius: 1em; margin: 0 auto; border:3px solid black; padding:5px; background-color:#ADDFFF;" cellpadding="4" cellspacing="4"
|<center>
<div style="font-size:162%; border:none; margin:0; padding:.1em; color:#000;">Thank you for reading</div><br/>
You may also find some other resources of ours useful in debate situations. Check out [[Research|research]] for a collection of scientific research and other demonstrative references on matters relevant to minor sexuality. [[People and Organisations|People and organisations]] is an easy to use database of all the individuals and organisations of interest to those who follow our [[Ethos of Newgon.com|ethos]]. [[Accounts and Testimonies|Our database of real-life stories]] lists personal testimonies intended to be used as evidence of positive relationships.  '''[[Links (Fora)]]''' documents some fora that may be receptive to your arguments and lists examples of this.


It also functions as centre for advice, links and external debate resources pertaining to these issues and the age of consent.
Debate Guide was written by a [[History and credits (Debate Guide)|'''range of authors during the years 2006-09''']]. If you are not pleased with the quality of Debate Guide, consider [[NewgonWiki:Getting involved|getting involved]]. From the simplest of corrections to the most complex of new arguments, we want to hear from you. Just drop by the '''[http://newgon.com/forum/viewtopic.php?id=506 feedback forum]''', or e-mail an administrator. You could even be given membership to edit this wiki!</center>
|}


==Introduction==
[[fr:Guide de débat]]
 
===[[Introduction to Debate Guide]]===
 
==General Advisory==
 
===[[Starting a Debate]]===
 
===Responding to Arguments===
 
*[[Debate Guide: Logical Fallacies and Intergenerational Sexuality|Logical Fallacies and Intergenerational Sexuality]]
*[[Debate Guide: Respond to Misdefinition|Respond to Misdefinition]] and [[Debate Guide: Myths|Myths]].
*[[Debate Guide: Respond to Rhetoric|Respond to Rhetoric]]
*[[Debate Guide: Social Constructionism|Social Constructionism]]
*[[Debate Guide: Other trends worth considering|Other trends worth considering]]
 
==Arguments: Assertive and Defensive==
 
==="Minor" Arguments===
 
*[[Debate Guide: Evolutionary Logic|Evolutionary Logic]] - Why CSA makes no sense in evolutionary terms.
*[[Debate Guide: Sexual Neglect|Sexual Neglect]].
*[[Debate Guide: Reverse Sexualisation|Reverse Sexualisation]] - Acknowledgement of sexuality in nude photography is revealing.
*[[Debate Guide: Liberty-Empowerment|Liberty-Empowerment]] - Empower young people with the freedom to learn.
*[[Debate Guide: Cyclical Paternalism|Cyclical Paternalism]] - Protecting children brings about the need to protect them more.
*[[Debate Guide: Prior Experience|Prior Experience]] - There is only one true way of gaining sexual experience.
*[[Debate Guide: The fallacy of "Sexual Maturity"|The fallacy of "Sexual Maturity"]]
*'''Against:''' [[Debate Guide: Cognitive Ability|Cognitive Ability]] - Some argue that sexual intimacy requires a level that minors have not yet reached.
*'''Against:''' [[Debate Guide: Online Dangers|Online Dangers]] - Argues against the idea of the internet being a dangerous place for minors.
*'''Against:''' [[Debate Guide: The kids do not want it|The kids do not want it]] - Disputes the claim that minors' general apathy in calling for reform counts as an argument against.
 
==="Adult" Arguments===
 
*[[Debate Guide: All child molesters are pedophiles|All child molesters are pedophiles]]
 
*'''Against:''' [[Debate Guide: Example Assertive|Example Assertive]]
 
==="Minor-Attraction" Arguments===
 
*[[Debate Guide: Example Assertive|Example Assertive]]
 
*'''Against:''' [[Debate Guide: Pedophiles chose their condition|Pedophiles chose their condition]]
*'''Against:''' [[Debate Guide: Pedophilia is unnatural|Pedophilia is unnatural]]
 
===Peripheral Arguments===
 
*[[Debate Guide: Child Abuse Industry|Child Abuse Industry]]
*[[Debate Guide: The Professional Victim|The Professional Victim]]
*[[Debate Guide: The nature of Human Attraction|The nature of Human Attraction]] - Why humans have a ''capacity'' for diverse taste.
*[[Debate Guide: The Hypocritical Establishment|The Hypocritical Establishment]] - Why concerns about child abuse may be disingenuous.
*[[Debate Guide: Sexual Repression as a tool of the State|Sexual Repression as a tool of the State]]
*[[Debate Guide: Historical Nonadult-Adult sex|Historical Nonadult-Adult sex]]
*[[Adverse effects of hysteria]]
*[[Debate Guide: Self-Loathing Hatred|Self-Loathing Hatred]]
*[[Debate Guide: Parenthood and Pedophilia|Parenthood and Pedophilia]]
*[[Debate Guide: Abuse of Language|Abuse of Language]]
*[[Debate Guide: Problems with the Age of Consent|Problems with the Age of Consent]]
*[[SOR Problems]] - Argues against the [[Sex Offenders' Register]]
 
*'''Against:''' [[Debate Guide: All Good Parents Would Know|All Good Parents Would Know]] - Some wrongly argue that only parents are qualified to make judgements.
 
==Debate Resources==
 
===[[Research]]===
 
A collection of scientific research and other demonstrative references on matters relevant to minor sexuality.
 
===[[Links (Debate Guide)]]===
 
Links that have some relevance to debating the issues contained within the guide.
 
===[[Links (Fora)]]===
 
Applicable forums and some examples of debates on the issues covered.
 
==About the Guide==
 
===[http://newgon.com/blog/?cat=12 What's new?]===
 
*Also see [[Special:Recentchanges|Recent Changes]]
 
===[http://newgon.com/feedback.php Feedback]===
 
===[[History and Credits (Debate Guide)]]===
 
==Newgon.com: Useful Stuff==
 
*[[People and Organisations]]
 
*[[Accounts and Testimonies]]
 
*[[Research]]
 
==Not Pleased?==
 
''Contribute!'' From the simplest of corrections to the most complex of new arguments, we want to hear from you. Just drop by the Blog or Forum, or e-mail an administrator. You could even be given membership to edit this wiki!

Revision as of 01:58, 21 May 2013

G O O G L E B O M B, BoyLover, GirlLover, Childlove, Pedophilia, Child, Rape, Sick, Evil, Jack McClellan, Pedo, Perverted Justice, Satanic Ritual Abuse, Human Trafficking, The truth about Paedophilia, Michael Jackson Pedophilia, Sarah Payne Murder, Soham Murders, NSPCC child abuse, Bruce Rind, PNVD pedophilia, pedophile party, pedopartij, NAMBLA, Daniel Lièvre, Tom O'Carroll, Paedophilia in Britain, USA, American pedophilia, Paedophile Information Exchange, UNCRC Convention, Children's rights, Child protection, Child sexual abuse, every child matters, debate, win arguments, discussion, pedobear, forum, bbs, bulletin board, loli, castorama, ricrisci, notamonster G O O G L E B O M B

Debate Guide is a growing list of arguments and counter arguments for the sexual emancipation of minors and minor attracted adults. It also functions as centre for advice, links and external debate resources pertaining to these issues and the age of consent. Why not consider reading our introduction or getting involved in the wider wiki project?


Advice

The task at hand...

Responding to others...

Arguments about pedophilia/other attractions

Too many people hold conflicting beliefs about pedophilia and other sexuality...

Popular anti-pedophile sentiments and common human flaws go hand in hand...

Pedophilia and human sexuality are mischaracterized and misunderstood...

Arguments about children and minors

People under the age of majority can be sexual...

Sexually repressing children and minors does not benefit them...

  • Against: Online dangers - The internet is generally not a dangerous place for minors.
  • Reverse sexualization - Popular acknowledgement of sexuality in nude photography is revealing.
  • Liberty-empowerment - Empowering young people will benefit them.
  • Turn of events - How the reporting and prosecution of sex can change the perspective of a youth.

Child advocacy is often illogical...

  • Against: The kids do not want it - Legal minors must supposedly "embrace" or "consent to" law reforms.
  • Against: Teen brain - Ideas of a distinct, or inferior "teen brain" are value-laden, outdated western pseudoscience.
  • Against: Corresponding age attraction - Questions the assumption of a unique "childhood" sexual orientation.

From the encyclopedia...

Arguments about adult-minor relationships

People fail to appreciate the flaws of Age of Consent laws...

Myths and bad meta-ethics plague discussions of expressed adult-minor sexuality...

Levels of harm are exaggerated and the sources are completely misunderstood...

Other societies and species are points of interest...

Many people also speak from direct experience...

Other arguments

Other arguments don't relate fundamentally to attractions, minors or relationships...

Debate Guide is a work in progress, and some material is undeveloped...

From the encyclopedia...


Thank you for reading

You may also find some other resources of ours useful in debate situations. Check out research for a collection of scientific research and other demonstrative references on matters relevant to minor sexuality. People and organisations is an easy to use database of all the individuals and organisations of interest to those who follow our ethos. Our database of real-life stories lists personal testimonies intended to be used as evidence of positive relationships. Links (Fora) documents some fora that may be receptive to your arguments and lists examples of this.

Debate Guide was written by a range of authors during the years 2006-09. If you are not pleased with the quality of Debate Guide, consider getting involved. From the simplest of corrections to the most complex of new arguments, we want to hear from you. Just drop by the feedback forum, or e-mail an administrator. You could even be given membership to edit this wiki!